Table of Contents
Understanding the health scare
Last Sunday night, Karin Martin found herself unable to sleep, gripped by anxiety after receiving a letter from Toronto Public Health. The letter, sent to 2,500 patients, revealed a serious concern: potential exposure to bloodborne viruses, including HIV, hepatitis B, and hepatitis C.
This alarming notification stemmed from a failure to adequately clean, disinfect, and sterilize medical instruments at the office of gynecologist Dr. Esther Park, located in the city’s west end. Patients who underwent procedures such as endometrial biopsies or IUD insertions between October 10, 2020, and October 10, 2024, were advised to get tested for infections.
The impact on patients
For Martin, who had undergone three biopsies with Dr. Park before her uterine cancer diagnosis, the letter was a painful reminder of her recent health struggles. “I was just trying to put it all behind me,” she shared, reflecting on the emotional toll of the situation.
The letter brought back memories of her emergency surgery and recovery, intensifying her worries about potential infections. Toronto Public Health confirmed that the investigation began after a patient complaint in September, revealing inadequate disinfection practices at Park’s clinic.
Ongoing investigations and patient concerns
As the investigation unfolds, the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario has also stepped in, examining infection control issues related to Dr. Park’s practice. Although no infections have been confirmed as a result of the clinic’s practices, the uncertainty leaves many patients feeling anxious.
Mickey Cirak, a communications adviser at the college, noted that Dr. Park is still permitted to practice under specific conditions, including engaging in professional education on medical record-keeping.
Shifting practices and patient experiences
In light of the situation, Toronto public health officials have recommended that Dr.
Park utilize single-use instruments whenever possible. However, patients like Lucie Stengs, who had her IUD insertion scheduled with Park, reported a noticeable change in the clinic’s atmosphere during her last visit. Stengs described her experience as unsettling, with Dr. Park appearing distracted and using single-use instruments instead of the usual metal ones. Although Stengs did not receive the health notification due to her appointment falling outside the specified dates, she expressed concern over the exclusion of patients who may also have been at risk.
Looking ahead
The situation raises critical questions about patient safety and the standards of care in medical practices. As Dr. Park prepares to retire and close her office in April, many patients are left grappling with uncertainty and anxiety over their health. The incident serves as a stark reminder of the importance of stringent sterilization practices in healthcare settings and the need for transparency in patient communications. As investigations continue, affected individuals are encouraged to seek medical advice and stay informed about their health.
